The Christmas Play

I was sick last week (stomach bug – my least favorite illness). It cost me a trip to Memphis where we were to spend a few days with family and the joy of watching two of my daughters singing in an Advent Festival. My many years of ministry have put me in some diverse places in the Christmas season. There have been years in store fronts, a warehouse, a warren of offices converted for worship, a borrowed recreation room in a YMCA, as well as churches whose beauty would take your breath away.

The early years of my Orthodoxy were filled with awkwardness (a form of shame), as we had so little guidance, so few resources, so few people, and more than a little interpersonal conflict. I remember in those days wanting to have a Christmas play in the Church (with children as sheep and shepherds, the Holy Family, and such). The tensions in our ragged little community left me frozen, unable to lead effectively. So, the season passed with the little that was “in the book” as I sought to reassure the cradle-born and the over-zealous converts among us that we were being authentically Orthodox and not some ersatz bastard mix. I hated it.

The fault was mine. I was a convert leader with too little Orthodox experience, too little support, and more than my share of shame and confusion. I have a chapter in my book, Face to Face, on the shame of conversion. Thank God that the decades that have followed have changed what is available for life in the Church. I have rarely written this honestly about how hard all of this was.

But in the context of Christmas, it was particularly painful.

This year, in the parish where I am now retired, there was a Christmas concert a week back (my wife sings in the choir) with a very full mix of Christmas hymns from East and West. There will also be a Christmas play – with children as shepherds, sheep, and what-not. It is an unanxious, unashamed, full-throated Orthodox Church where over 400 gather on Sundays for worship. I do not have to make decisions nor referee anyone’s feelings. I just serve.

Christmas permeates our culture like no other Christian feast. The Orthodox know and understand that Pascha (Easter) is the “Queen of Feasts,” the greatest of all days. Indeed, Christmas is understood to be the “Winter Pascha.” But in a culture driven by commercialism, Christmas is king. There are ENORMOUS decorations on the lawns of houses here and there. The South goes “tacky” for Christmas which is saying something.

But I love it.

After I began to recover from my sick bed, I was hungry for some human touch of the holiday. I went for a brief walk in nearby town. People were out shopping, browsing, and generally being happy. A couple of strangers greeted me on the street telling me that I looked “sharp.” These were kind words in that I felt like a “coat on a stick.”

In the culture at large, Christmas tends to change people. Not always. Not everywhere. But it’s noticeable. There is a cheer – a bonhomie. As I walked my few blocks, I suddenly felt that I was in a Christmas play as large as the world itself. Shepherds and children, sheep and angels, a Wise Man here and there, gold and a bit of incense, with cinnamon and peppermint as well. We were traveling to Bethlehem to a Child in the Cave.

The first Christmas was not safe. It took place while a conspiracy that would murder 10,000 innocents was being enacted. The birth was followed by some years as a refugee in Egypt.

There is a television production of a Mexican version of the Christmas play (La Pastorela) with Linda Ronstadt, Cheech and Chong, and a wonderful cast of characters. It is a presentation in which violence and danger and battles with temptations and demons dog every step of the journey. It is a reminder that Christmas is not a shopping spree nor just tinsel and toys. Christmas is spiritual warfare. Without a miracle, there is no Christmas. You might add it to your watchlist this year.

The whole world is a Christmas play because the Christ Child has come among us. The angels have given instructions for us all: “Peace on earth, goodwill among men.” Remember the children everywhere. Pray for the sheep and the shepherds. Venerate the Wise Men and follow their example. May God save us all from wicked King Herod and his minions. May the Mother of God pray for us and give us humble words of praise for the King of Peace.

The Play has begun.

About Fr. Stephen Freeman

Fr. Stephen is a retired Archpriest of the Orthodox Church in America. He is also author of Everywhere Present: Christianity in a One-Storey Universe, and Face to Face: Knowing God Beyond Our Shame, as well as the Glory to God podcast series on Ancient Faith Radio.



Posted

in

, ,

by

Comments

24 responses to “The Christmas Play”

  1. Liz Flowers Avatar
    Liz Flowers

    Great reflection! Well said and so balanced.

  2. Alison Morris Avatar
    Alison Morris

    This was beautiful. Thank you!

  3. Mark Spurlock Avatar
    Mark Spurlock

    Thank you, Father Stephen, for a timely and personal meditation.

    I’m listening to St John of the Ladder’s concert this morning while doing seasonal things. Do you know of where the program of selections is listed?

  4. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Mark,
    There’s no electronic version. I’ll see what i can come up with

  5. Matthew Avatar
    Matthew

    Why didn’t the cradle Orthodox and the converts want a Christmas play?

  6. Bryan (Emmanuel) Elderkin Avatar
    Bryan (Emmanuel) Elderkin

    Glad you are up and around Fr! May your recovery be complete. It always seems that an illness that sidelines broadens and deepens (if only for too brief a moment!) our appreciation of ‘life’, and especially our awareness of God’s Infinite Mercy, Love, and Presence. Kalo Christouyena! Blessed Nativity!
    Your blog is a ‘gift’ to me.

  7. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Matthew,
    First, this would have been in 1998-99. The landscape was very different than today. We were small (25 people or so). The internet was still in its infancy. There was no Youtube, so no real exposure to what was done elsewhere. Our handful of cradle-born either had European backgrounds or Greek. There was very poor communication in the diocese, and I was not ordained priest until March of 99, which limited a lot of what we could do. I think there was an air of uncertainty in our community. Uncertainty of me and my leadership (which was heightened by my own uncertainties). Our converts at the time were mostly former Anglicans. So, anytime I suggested or did anything that had kinship with my former Anglicanism, there were tensions and quiet criticisms of “he’s still Anglican”. The emotional tenor of the place was very eggshell-like (including me).

    So, I didn’t trust my own instincts and had too little information for decision-making. Those were hard days. I also was working a full-time job to support my family.

    But, the landscape changed. I was ordained in ’99. I was learning all the time. Communication improved. We grew. We lost a few members and gained more and slowly began to stabilize. It took about a decade or so. That’s not unusual. Mission-planting is always hard.

    When I retired, the parish had about 250 (Pascha numbers). I had a hand in starting 5 churches that still exist. Time took care of a lot.

    There was a sense among some, in those earliest years, that the Christmas traditions many cherished (like pageants and carols) were Protestant and Western. It’s not actually true – but I didn’t know enough then to feel comfortable leading us past such false ideas. These were growing pains.

    Every generation brings its own troubles. These days, Orthodox Churches in America are dealing with a flood of converts. There are new challenges. But the landscape has changed. As I noted in the article, none of my early experience is echoed in the very mature, large (mostly convert) parish in which I’ve retired. Orthodoxy is less nervous these days, I think.

    Also, a lot of the story that I share in the article was my fault – or due to my own personal/emotional circumstances. But I learned a lot. It helped me write books and articles and offer helpful insights for others.

  8. Matthew Avatar
    Matthew

    Thanks so much for sharing more from your journey. What a story Fr. Stephen!

  9. Seraphim Avatar
    Seraphim

    Reading this gave me chills!
    Just thinking about the mom and the father Joseph and the baby, surrounded by strangers, the three wise men making sacrifices of their own personal wealth at a miraculous event.
    Glory to God for all things.

  10. Jenny Avatar
    Jenny

    Father,

    For the past couple of weeks I have been caught in waves of anger and unrest and urgency. No matter what I was doing, my thoughts were fomenting on frustration, fear, anger and outrage.

    Countless times a day I’d pull out my phone and get lost in yet another story, yet another tragedy, unable to look away, unable to know what to do, how to respond.

    The grace which I learned years ago in repenting from making an idol of my country, an idol of politics, that hard learned quietness of soul I learned by resting my faith on Christ alone, I lost that.

    How many times will I have to learn the same lesson over again? I wish I could walk a straight path. But I keep falling into pits, the same pit I’d fallen into before.

    Hourly, I would be asking the Lord to forgive me and then be on my phone again. Beg for forgiveness and then be on social media again not 20 minutes later.

    My husband would be talking to me. I’d have eye contact and my thoughts would be gone, gripped by incessant internal dialogue about what was happening in the world, in current events.

    My thoughts would return to my husband just in time for him to finish talking, and I would realize I hadn’t heard a word he’d said, though I’d been looking straight at him the whole time. Just this morning this happened again.

    It’s so torturous, because things are terrible. They feel so urgent. I feel waves of urgency wash over me, when I think of my children, of their future, of the world we live in. How am I supposed to respond?

    I couldn’t find a place for my mind to rest. “Please help me find a place for my mind to rest,” I’d ask the Lord. “Please help. Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner.”

    Two nights ago, when I asked Him again, He reminded me of this verse: “Trust in the Lord with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding; in all your ways submit to him, and he will make your paths straight.”

    So I have been trying to let go of understanding things on my own. That’s the hardest part. How do I undermine what is best for me to do as a Christian? I didn’t know how to answer the question, so I couldn’t rest.

    But I tried to give up leaning on my own understanding and instead acknowledge Him in all I did: “Lord, I am caught up in this again. Here I am, I am acknowledging You as my Lord. Have mercy on me, a sinner.”

    And that did help. Then I read this article and the waves of passionate emotions began to grow more and more quiet. I am so grateful that you have gotten better and are able to write again.

    Unfortunately, I sent my poor father a very angry message and so I’m going to write and ask his forgiveness for venting my frustration on him.

    Again as before, I cannot help but recognize that it is by the grace of God alone that I am able to stand at all. It’s truly disconcerting to realize how weak I am under pressure. Equally difficult to grasp is the sheer grace of our Lord in His faithfulness and steadfast love. I fail Him so many times, but He never fails me. He always reaches down and pulls me out of the mire and puts me on the solid rock.

    Father, do you think it really is true that acquiring a spirit of peace could actually save thousands? If so, if such a thing is that spirituality effective, then I think I will try to die completely to the idea of trying to do anything else. I will fail to do it, though. I will fail repeatedly. But perhaps just moving in that direction is worth doing?

  11. David Avatar
    David

    Hi Jenny, my heart ached on hearing your struggle ,with many echoes of my own experience in recent times. Despite having removed myself from wall to wall activity on Instagram and X posting angst-ridden and judgemental takes on the horrors of the globalist tyranny all around, I still find myself playing out in my head raging arguments with once close friends over why they cannot see what is happening. But Christ has a way of bringing us back – if we just allow Him to – and not a little despair provided me with the fuel to respond. I came back to faith nearly three years ago and then converted to Orthodoxy, together with my wife – our chrismation last Palm Sunday. I had last worshipped some 25 years ago, in an evangelical church in our local town in Buckinghamshire England. A ten minute walk to church has now become a 45 minute drive to our Orthodox Church – so few and far between are they here in England. The Church is growing, as it is in America. I do though partly miss the hymns and the Christmas Carols. So I found much encouragement from Fr Stephen that some of those seemingly protestant-only ways could still find a small place in our Orthodox spiritual lives.
    And, thank you Fr Stephen. Your weekly homilies are always beautifully written and deeply thought-provoking.

  12. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    David,
    That you are attending Church after 25 years, and found your way to Orthodoxy (with 45 minutes for preparation!) in England – does my heart incredible good, and suggests that somewhere in England, some number are acquiring the Spirit of Peace! May God multiply and give increase to your faith and to the brothers and sisters of your land.

  13. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Jenny,
    The Spirit of Peace is pretty much the only way good comes. We see “general” trends in the world around us. But none of us (including our children and grandchildren) live in general. We only live in particular. And any of us, by grace, in particular can live contrary to the spirit of this age and in harmony with the Incarnate Christ.

    None of us can judge what is going on around us. The pandemic looked to be about as demonic as any could imagine, and yet the current flood of converts coming into the Church (my diocese has doubled in numbers since the pandemic) is itself somehow related to that tragic interruption of our lives. What the enemy meant to us for evil, the Lord meant to us for good. When we hear bad news (the work of the enemy) we should rejoice knowing that God will work something far greater for our good.

    Blessings!

  14. Dee of Sts Herman and Olga Avatar
    Dee of Sts Herman and Olga

    Dear Father,
    Thank you for this article and your response to Jenny. Both tie in well together to help me face current events in my work life with confidence and courage (“God will work something far greater for our good”) and to participate with exuberance and enjoy the season of the Nativity. “Glad tidings” indeed!!

  15. Eric N Dunn Avatar
    Eric N Dunn

    Thankyou for that much needed dose of reality.

  16. Donald Vladimir Roberts Avatar
    Donald Vladimir Roberts

    Thank you so very much Fr Stephen for letting me and all Christians know about “La Pastorellas”, the movie. I’ve never heard about it before. It was truly a Christmas gift to me!

    I was brought up in a Christian family on Vancouver Island in British Columbia. We went to the United Church. I’m sad to see how much that church has changed… I think you know what I mean.

    Since that time I met and married a wonderful Orthodox woman from Russia. We are in Russia now caring for her mother. I am deeply blessed to be an Orthodox Christian! To actually worship The Father and The Son and The Holy Spirit in a church the way that Jesus told the Apostles to design and run a church is so obviously the most fulfilling way to be a Christian and deeply worship.

  17. Jenny Avatar
    Jenny

    Father,

    I have been doing a lot of “debriefing” I suppose one could call it, in the last 48 hours or so- thinking about what I moved through and what you wrote about the Spirit of Peace. I suppose you could say I am now laying out my homework as it has been completed so far. I don’t think it’s finished yet.

    It’s so difficult to let go of the idea that things cannot be fixed through reasoning or passionate pleading or facts or historical precedent or patterns. Or at least, that they don’t have the kind of impact that I have been longing for them to have, expecting them to have.

    When something terrible happens, or destructive patterns emerge, my natural impulse is of course to fix it, to correct course.

    But how to truly do this? If I post something on social media, the algorithm will sweep it away, or it will get caught up in a rising tide of collective human passion. I myself will get caught up in this tide.

    And still the horrible thing remains, the injustice remains. So then do I up the ante, as it were, and band together with like minded individuals and attempt political action?

    But now I truly am caught up in a mass of human passions moving somewhere together and how does one control that and how can lasting good come out of this type of energy? It seems to always create unintended negative consequences, falls far short of what was needed, and injustice remains or regrows in another area.

    At one of the worst points as I was struggling with these feelings, the Lord told me to pray for those that I was especially angry at- specifically to include them in the prayers for my children.

    It was a peculiar, awkward experience at first. For example, “Oh God, our Heavenly Father, Who lovest mankind and are most merciful and compassionate, have mercy upon our children, Thy servants, Merissa and John and (all these people that I feel certain wish them harm), and grant them all to Thy gracious protection… Lead them in the path of Thy truth and draw them near to Thee…”

    It was eye opening. it saved me from going right off that cliff. In praying this way, I saw that prayer like that was far more effective than anything else I could do.

    But I still could not rid myself of the feelings outrage and anger for quite some time even after I began praying like this. I didn’t want to give up entirely on the idea of some emotionally laden effort on my part.

    To give that up felt like making myself and my children helpless. It was this type of thought that was making it hard for me to let go.

    I’ve seen the preview of the new Avatar movie coming out, and it seems to capture exactly the sort of thing that is so seductive, that appears so satisfying- unleashing righteous rage at the forces of evil and subduing them with that glorious appearing anger.

    My goodness, how I wish that worked. But I know it’s an awful lie in terms of true spirituality. For myself, it is merely a seductive temptation. It’s not that I can’t be angry per se, it’s just that my anger, in fact, my whole self has to be completely submitted to Christ.

    Isn’t that being meek? It’s extremely difficult to do, because it doesn’t mean feeling nothing or weakness or apathy. It means that one is holding one’s passionate heart still in submission to the Lord.

    The thing is, all my human efforts are like dust in the wind. Even if I gathered up a whole bunch of human effort, all working together, it would still be this in the end.

    But the Lord, who can stop Him? He can throw light into the darkest human heart. He can speak to persons I could never reach. The Lord’s word never comes back to Him void. It brings forth that which He intends for it to do.

    One might say that He is working far above the whirlwind, in ways and patterns that are far beyond us and entirely good. He does bring forth good out of evil. That’s His work and nothing can stop it.

    So I want to give up entirely any hope of doing something on my own. Even if it makes me feel vulnerable, even if I must give up the satisfying feeling of self righteousness, glorious appearing anger so that instead my heart can be quiet enough to hear and to move in prayer with the Spirit of Peace and trust Him in all things.

    Even to my own father, with that close relationship, even with all my clearest reasoning and most persuasive emotion, I cannot change even his mind.

    But if I pray with a quiet, trusting heart for a person who has made themselves my enemy, even for a person who would physically kill me if they could, who can say where the prayer would go? What could limit the reach of that prayer? Only the Lord Himself determines it.

    So I’m going to be trying to do that now. Whatever else I do, I will only try to do with a quiet, submitted heart, knowing that it is the Lord’s work that is the most effective. I will try and let the peace of Christ act as umpire in my heart, as the verse says:

    And let the peace (soul harmony which comes) from Christ rule (act as umpire continually) in your hearts [deciding and settling with finality all questions that arise in your minds, in that peaceful state] to which as [members of Christ’s] one body you were also called [to live]. And be thankful (appreciative), [giving praise to God always]. -Colossians 3:15

    Or anyway, I will try to do this. I will make that the mark so I know which direction to go back to when I veer away. I won’t try to do anything else. That’s as far as I’ve gotten on my homework. 🙂

  18. Jenny Avatar
    Jenny

    David,

    Thank you so much for your encouraging and sympathetic comment! Our stories do have a lot in common. I am so thankful the Lord draws us back home to Him and gives us peace. It is so encouraging to know that the Orthodox Church is growing there too! Praise God!

  19. Dee of Sts Herman and Olga Avatar
    Dee of Sts Herman and Olga

    Father,
    I received this quote today. May I ask for your comment.

    Abandon that deceptive thought that in some far away place you will humble yourself and will bear every disparagement and humiliation, but rather humble yourself at the present time and in the present place where you live, and in your thoughts consider yourself beneath the feet of everyone, i.e., consider yourself worthy of every disparagement, humiliation, and vexation.” St. Ambrose

    Without such acceptance of disparagement and humiliation, should we assume we are far from God, and therefore should seek forgiveness and the heart for such acceptance? Among some of our living saints, I have perceived such humility. But I’m not sure it is our aspiration among the laity in general. How do we express such acceptance and yet not invite potential injury (psychological or of the soul, even of the one dishing out the disparagement) to others?

  20. Byron Avatar
    Byron

    Dee,

    I think it can be easy to humble oneself in the “big picture”. As an example, during great persecution one can be humble, realizing one’s helplessness, and throw oneself before God. But in the small persecutions of life–the laughter of others at you, the abusive workings of an uncaring system, or the daily belittling of those who enjoy putting us underneath them–it is very difficult to be humble.

    My instinct is always to rise up, to beat them at their own game, to take advantage of loopholes, and in all ways to put myself in certain advantage over the other in my daily dealings with them. I listen to others not to hear, but to hear what I might use to my advantage. I consider the snide comeback and look for the opportunity to use it. I look for the loophole to take advantage of the process. I place myself in a secure setting and wait, with expectation, for them to fail.

    I don’t think we are far from God when we do not accept being disparaged and humbled by the world around us. I think we are far from God when we scheme to withstand such things without love for others. Pride, and prideful reaction, can be a measure for us in these situations, I think.

    Forgive me if I misunderstood your question. These are just my thoughts.

  21. Dee of Sts Herman and Olga Avatar
    Dee of Sts Herman and Olga

    Dear Byron,
    Thank you so much for your response. Your words are helpful.

  22. Kenneth Avatar
    Kenneth

    Where can La Pastorela with English subtitles be found? I found only the original Spanish version, which I can follow a little bit but my family can’t.

  23. Kenneth Avatar
    Kenneth

    Thanks, Fr. Stephen! I loved your reflection on the Christmas Play. Merry Christmas!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Subscribe to blog via email

Support the work

Your generous support for Glory to God for All Things will help maintain and expand the work of Fr. Stephen. This ministry continues to grow and your help is important. Thank you for your prayers and encouragement!


Latest Comments

  1. Thanks for that great advice, Fr Stephen. The Fathers and others writing before 1500 would surely be the best resources.…

  2. Dear Fr Stephen Thank you for another great article. This article is interestingly timed. In just over a week, I…

  3. This is the actual quote for those who are wondering, the one that is circulating on the internet and appears…


Read my books

Everywhere Present by Stephen Freeman

Listen to my podcast



Categories


Archives