In a Single Moment


In Holy Week, the Church remembers the “Wise Thief,” the robber on the cross who asks Christ to “remember me in your kingdom.” In what has to be one of my favorite hymns of the week the Church sings:

The Wise Thief didst Thou make worthy of Paradise, in a single moment, O Lord. By the wood of thy Cross illumine me as well, and save me.

The striking part of this hymn is the phrase, “In a single moment.” From a modern evangelical point of view there is nothing terribly significant in this event. Here is Jesus with two thieves. Everyone is being crucified. One of them simply professes faith in Christ and is rewarded with the promise, “Today you will be with me in paradise.”

Orthodoxy marvels at this for a variety of reasons. One of them is the suddenness of the moment. As far as we know, the thief was a thief and, as he himself confesses, “We are suffering the just penalty for our crimes.” He has not been a follower of Christ.

All of this is further mediation on the earlier question, “How do we come to believe in Christ?” We cannot analyze the technique of Christ on the Cross. We do not hear Jesus saying to the two thieves, “You know, all of your righteousness is as filthy rags, but if you place your faith in me you can be saved…” or some such version of modern evangelical proclamation.

He had not said anything to them.

What we have is one of those strange moments that the Kingdom of God breaks through in a human life and in this case, the hardened heart of a thief, a man who made his living breaking into to people’s homes and stealing, simply hears the truth in a context in which his heart has changed.

“In a single moment,” the hymn says. This is an Orthodox wonderment, because we, appropriately, “work out our salvation” as a life-long process. Struggling, fasting, praying, giving-alms, repenting, seeking salvation – and here, a thief, who has done none of these things, finds that in a single moment paradise is his.

It is a testimony to us of the mercy of God. He would accept us in a single moment. It is not harder than that.

But rare is it in our lives that we allow ourselves to come to such a moment. We live carefully – carefully enough that unless something really bad comes along we have avoided such a single moment. In some ways, our salvation is lived out over a lifetime because we are afraid to have it “in a single moment.”

It is true that some evangelicals trivialize the “singleness of the moment,” requiring virtually nothing, and getting almost as much in return.

On the other hand, we Orthodox can be guilty of ignoring the power of a single moment. The great startsy (elders) of our tradition were not afraid to bring people to such moments. It’s part of the stuff that makes them famous.

Matthew the Poor, the Coptic monk who has been so influential in the 20th century, once wrote that if we kept even one of Christ commandments with “all our heart, soul and mind,” it would become for us the door to the Kingdom of God. This is true, but the implication is that we rarely keep any of the commandments in such a manner. We do not pray like the thief, we do not repent like the thief, we do not see Jesus like the thief or ourselves like the thief. We see so much more incrementally, and thus risk our salvation over such a long period of our lives.

How do we come to know Christ? “In a single moment if we wished it.” And this I can say to any Orthodoxy brother or sister. “In a single moment if you wished it.”

And it brings me up short. In a single moment I want to be left alone, to take a break, to think about something else, to tend to a lesser matter, to take care of a Church job (who knows what things I’d rather do than that single moment). But in a single moment we could know paradise. May we know such a single moment, and perhaps not so long from now.

About Fr. Stephen Freeman

Fr. Stephen is a priest of the Orthodox Church in America, Pastor Emeritus of St. Anne Orthodox Church in Oak Ridge, Tennessee. He is also author of Everywhere Present and the Glory to God podcast series.





4 responses to “In a Single Moment”

  1. Meg Lark Avatar
    Meg Lark

    One of my favorite references to this is in the Matins hymns for Wednesdays and Fridays (can’t recall which Tone, but I suspect it’s Tone 6, since it’s so fresh in my mind), which note that the thief was exceedingly skilled, because he “stole” paradise by his confession of faith. Of such thievery should we all be capable!

  2. Michael Bauman Avatar
    Michael Bauman

    Perhaps we avoid “that single moment” because we intuitively know that Paradise is on the other side of the Cross.

  3. Michael Bauman Avatar
    Michael Bauman

    In light of Fr. Hopko’s commentary on the Apocalypse that we are living in the Tribulation and will until our Lord comes again, perhaps we have many “moments” in our life in which we enter into paradise through the Cross. Then, like the Deacon in the Liturgy come out again to share and to call others.

    Perhaps each time we have one of those “moments” (with another assist from Narnia) we go “higher up and further in”.

  4. Fr Stephen Avatar
    Fr Stephen

    I like that image. With joy, I’m meeting this afternoon with a newly ordained Deacon in our parish, so we can practice going “higher up and further in.” Both of us hope for very little Tribulation in the process!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to blog via email

Support the work

Your generous support for Glory to God for All Things will help maintain and expand the work of Fr. Stephen. This ministry continues to grow and your help is important. Thank you for your prayers and encouragement!

Latest Comments

  1. Carlos, thanks for your reply. Even if the prayers are first person singular, they are for all of us to…

  2. Janine, Yes! I’ve read about the ancient corporate sense and its interpretive power in scripture, but I’m hesitant to apply…

  3. Kenneth, thanks for that reminder about John the Baptist. Carlos, I kind of think that we are confusing ancient forms…

  4. Janine, Thank you for replying! I understand what you’re saying about unworthiness and I totally agree, it is absolutely by…

  5. Father Stephen, Thank you for zeroing in on the shame and recommending your book. I look forward to reading it!

Read my books

Everywhere Present by Stephen Freeman

Listen to my podcast