Everything is in Motion

For years I have been told that the meaning of the word hamartia (translated “sin”) means “to miss the mark.” This is certainly accurate. However, the image I have always had in mind has been an arrow aimed at a target and missing the bull’s eye. Thus I have thought of my life as a moral effort to hit the target. This is not incorrect but it leaves out important information. God is the target (not an abstract moral standard) and we ourselves are the arrow. There is a great tendency in our thought to conceive things in stationary, static images. Such images are easier to conceive and explain. Setting everything in motion complicates our efforts to comprehend. However, it is essential to understand that everything is in motion. Oddly, this concept is not some post-modernist imagery of dancing Wu-Li Masters: it is part of the teaching of the fathers of the Church.

The idea of movement and change (both in time and space) was not original with great teachers of the Church (such as St. Basil, St. Gregory of Nyssa, Pseudo-Dionysius or St. Maximus the Confessor). These thoughts originated long before with philosophers such as Plato and Heraclitus. But the fathers of the Church took up the concept and refined it for the use of Christian theology. God’s creation (as we should well know) is everywhere in motion. Every object in the universe is moving (further apart we are told). Even the particles of matter that compose so-called stationery objects (such as rocks) are in motion. Nothing is completely at rest. It is odd for a modern man to discover that such thought is in no way new. However, movement is not the only thing of importance in this patristic understanding of creation. Everything is in motion, and everything has its direction. That direction is its purpose – its reason for existence and reason for continuing in existence. This reason is its logos. The Logos of all logoi (plural), is Christ Himself.

In the beginning was the Logos, and the Logos was with God and the Logos was God. All things were made through Him…  (Jn. 1:1)

Each of us has a purpose and reason for existence. For human beings (and all creation), that purpose is union with God.

… [God has made known to us] the mystery of His will, according to His good pleasure which He purposed in Himself, that in the economy of the fullness of times he might gather together in one all things in Christ, both which are in heaven and which are on earth…

It is this purpose and direction that are the mark towards which we move. Whatever causes us to deviate from that mark is what is meant by the Biblical word “sin.” Moving away from the mark distorts our purpose, our inner relationship with God. The result is death and corruption. Christ restores our right relationship with God and through that living communion restores our purpose and direction. We move rightly towards the end for which we were created. Salvation, like all things in God’s creation, is dynamic and not static. Those who reduce salvation to a single moment, “I was saved,” run the risk of distorting the proper understanding of the Christian life. The injection of discrete moments of history (“I made a decision for Christ”) can be misunderstood as describing something which happens once and is finished. But we are moving. A “decision for Christ” is properly a description of a direction rather than a destination.

As directions, our lives need to be referred to Christ at  every moment and in every place. Living as part of a vast swirl of movement can be dizzying. It is little wonder that we want to re-imagine the universe in a stable, static form. But the universe will not stand still for such imagination. It continues to swirl while we stare at our delusion. It is customary in some of the monasteries of Mt. Athos to set the central chandelier in motion during the singing of the “polyelion” (the hymn “for His mercy endures forever”) of the all-night vigil. Sometimes the lamps before the icons swing as well. I have heard it described as representing the dancing of the angels before God. It certainly incorporates movement within the worship of the Church. For the liturgy is a great dance – the proper movement of creation itself. We were created as a movement. The continual offering of ourselves to God in praise and thanksgiving is the fulfillment of our very being. We do not need to comprehend the universe. We need to be swept towards Christ.

Some thoughts from St. Dionysius the Areopagite on our motion…

From this Beauty comes the existence of everything,
each being exhibiting its own way of beauty.
For Beauty is the cause of harmony, of sympathy, and of community.
Beauty unites all things and is the source of all things.
Beauty is the great creating cause which bestirs the world
and holds all things in existence by the longing inside
them to have Beauty.

And there it is ahead of all as Goal, as the Beloved,
as the Cause toward which all things move,
since it is the longing for Beauty which actually
brings them into being.

Beauty is a model to which they conform…
From the One, the Good, the Beautiful –
the interrelationship of all things in accordance with capacity.

From the One, the Good, the Beautiful –
the harmony and the love which are formed
between them but which do not obliterate identity.

From the One, the Good, the Beautiful –
the innate togetherness of everything.

From the One, the Good, the Beautiful, also –
the intermingling of everything, the persistence of things,
the unceasing emergence of things…

~ St. Dionysios the Areopagite, Divine Names, 4.7

About Fr. Stephen Freeman

Fr. Stephen is a retired Archpriest of the Orthodox Church in America. He is also author of Everywhere Present: Christianity in a One-Storey Universe, and Face to Face: Knowing God Beyond Our Shame, as well as the Glory to God podcast series on Ancient Faith Radio.



Posted

in

,

by

Comments

32 responses to “Everything is in Motion”

  1. Cleo Bibas Avatar
    Cleo Bibas

    Beautiful, very touching post!!💖

  2. Jörgen I Eriksson Avatar

    Everything is in motion – indeed! Then, also God must be in constant, dynamic motion. Continously changing….

  3. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Jörgen,
    Classically, we would say that God is the “Unmoved Mover,” or as the Scriptures say, “He is the same yesterday, today, and forever.” I think we can say that He moves as a mover is present in that which he moves. But He is the Beginning and the End. The place from which everything moves and the place towards which everything moves.

    In a number of the Church Fathers, they speak of Him as being “at rest.”

  4. Jörgen I Eriksson Avatar

    God as being “at rest” is hard for me to grasp. My experience from 40 years of shamanic work points in a somewhat different direction, namely that God, or the name I prefer – The Great Mystery, or The Cosmic Consciousness – is constantly changing, in ways that we hardly can grasp or understand but that we can experience. So what do you do when your experience contradicts that which is considered to be some kind of eternal truth within orthodoxy?

  5. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    I have not found my experience to be something that trumps the collective wisdom of the Orthodox faith across the centuries. One guy and his experience is just asking for trouble…everyone needs guidance. I’m an Eastern Orthodox priest, for what it’s worth. I would not want to confuse my experience with God. What I know of God is what (Who) has been made known to me in the God/Man, Jesus Christ. When I say, “God,” I am referring to that – not to my unaided experience.

  6. Jenny Avatar
    Jenny

    Father,

    “And there it is ahead of all as Goal, as the Beloved,
    as the Cause toward which all things move,
    since it is the longing for Beauty which actually
    brings them into being.”

    When this passage says, “…since it is the longing for Beauty which actually brings them into being,” does it mean the Lord was longing for beauty and so brought us forth in His image to be drawn to Him?

    By the way, I have added peaches to my shopping list. 🙂

  7. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Jenny,
    Enjoy the peaches!

    Your question is interesting – the idea there (and it strikes us as strange) is that it was the desire for beauty within non-being that drew it into existence (being). Thus, being itself is a movement towards Beauty. It’s stated as a bit of a mystery – in that we ask, “How can non-being (nothing) desire anything?” But, we can also ask, “How can God bring something out of nothing?” But this notion that that-which-exists has an inherent drive towards Beauty is important. I would even suggest that we only begin to understand anything when we allow it to teach us what it “knows” about Beauty.

  8. Michael Bauman Avatar
    Michael Bauman

    Father, it seems to me that “JOY” is the quality missing from this discussion. JOY is what holds everything together, moves and gives meaning to existence

  9. Michael Bauman Avatar
    Michael Bauman

    Father, it seems the quality missing is JOY.

  10. Jenny Avatar
    Jenny

    Father,

    Yes, that idea- that non being could be drawn into existence by a longing for the Beauty perfectly expressed in God- was so foreign to my thinking that I was trying to think of another way of understanding it. I’m used to thinking that everything was created by and for Christ.

    But as I ponder it, it’s no contradiction to say that anything brought into existence by the Lord would be drawn to Him even before He brought them forth. Anything good would wish to exist for His sake.

    I have also never considered the idea that we only begin to understand something unless we learn what it teaches us about beauty, but what an illuminating idea! When we come to define beauty, in Orthodox phronema, it means Christ Crucified? Because that it also when He is glorified.

    So to look for the beauty in something would be to see where it has patient, self sacrificing love- that is, we would understand it in that light?

  11. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Jenny,
    Indeed, Beauty is Christ Crucified. To see that love in each thing is a way of approaching that question.

  12. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Michael,
    I think that joy is a quality of love, or even of beauty. St. Dionysius used the term “eros” when he described creation in this manner.

  13. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Jenny,
    I will note that I’ve only ever seen the idea of the desire or longing towards Beauty as God’s means of creation in St. Dionysius. But it’s a very rich image.

  14. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Michael,
    I recall that Christ “went to the Cross for the joy that was set before Him,” so it should be mentioned within all this as well.

  15. Dirk Avatar
    Dirk

    Joergen: From a Christian perspective, if you wanted to imagine that God is moving, you could think of the Son as the good shephered going after the lost sheep and bringing them home (back to the Father). Or in other words, restoring us to the beauty we were created for.
    This movement is implied when Jesus says “follow me”. But movement is only meaningful in relation to God as the central point of reference.
    It is a bit like when you are in a train at a station and the a train next to you takes off – in that moment you experience movement but can’t know which train is actually moving.

  16. Paul Hughes Avatar

    Truly, a kinetic faith.

  17. Dee of Sts. Herman and Olga Avatar
    Dee of Sts. Herman and Olga

    Father,
    It is this dynamic aspect emphasized in Orthodoxy that allowed me to read the “sewer of seeds” parable in a new way. Seeing in myself the poor soil in which the seeds do not thrive, I felt sometimes a kind of hopelessness. But in the dynamic understanding of our salvation, Christ continually sends His seeds (or His Bread) our way regardless of the state of our soil. Perhaps in some places in our soul’s soil is good ground for the seed to take root and grow strong. Nevertheless, the Lord keeps sending His seed. Glory to God for His dynamic mercy.

    P.S. I love the quote from St. Dionysios the Areopagite. May He open our eyes to see His Beauty, in ourselves, in each other, in the goodness wherever we find it in this world, His creation.

  18. Robert Avatar
    Robert

    Experience alone is untrustworthy. Without some rather potent ideas and observations most of us are (no disrespect intended) not smart enough to arrive at independently, we would all believe it is not Earth moving, but the Sun and everything else. And yet, we know ( mostly because we have been taught so) the Earth moves around the Sun. That the Sun also moves is very hard to measure. Why? Because everything else is moving.

    I do not know when “making a decision for Jesus”, saying the Sinner’s prayer etc crept into practice but what a terrible toll such “once saved, always saved” notions levy. Salvation is a process, not an event. We are all in motion. But unlike Sol, God does not move. How do I know that? I have been taught. I am far too dumb and foolish to have discovered that on my own.

    Thank you Father. I needed to read this.

  19. Michael Bauman Avatar
    Michael Bauman

    Robert, as I have said experience is essential, but you are correct: experience has to be in the correct and righteous context i.e. correct theology in the broadest sense which includes the visual, e.g. icons and vestments. Auditory: sacramental music and the Sacraments themselves. Emotional: Joy and Thanksgiving in the middle of hardship.

    It also has to be administered by qualified priests and bishops and/or hierarchs.

    There are a lot of ways of interpretation and practice and no theology is perfect. But I maintain that theology without demonstration i.e. practice; is dead and far to easy to manipulate, and used for control.

  20. Anna Avatar
    Anna

    Amen !
    Thank you Father

  21. Sam Avatar
    Sam

    Dear Fr Stephen

    Thank you for another beautiful post. Do you think the connection between hamartia and man not fulfilling his telos in the Logos is also relevant to the consecration of objects such as Holy Water? The whole post made me think of Fr Alexander Schmemann’s discussions on secularism and the definition of holy in the context of Holy Water. In the Crux Fidelis chant from the 6th century, it speaks of the water and blood coming from Christ’s side washing clean the earth, seas, and stars, which I had previously thought strange. Nonetheless, if creation was “subjected to futility” and “groans in pain”, could it be that man’s deviation from his telos, being the priest of creation, affected the ability of the whole creation to fulfil its telos and that Christ’s obedience to the Father in the flesh mystically helps the whole creation once again achieve its telos? Fr Schmemann’s discussion of Holy Wated being water restored to its original purpose would seem to fit with this idea.

    God bless

  22. Dee of Sts Herman and Olga Avatar
    Dee of Sts Herman and Olga

    Sam,
    I think the Fathers say something like what you’re referring to in Fr. Schmemann’s writing. And I have also heard (I’m not sure where in the moment) that the dynamic process of our own salvation draws the rest of creation with us into our salvation, that is, Christ. Internally, we are a microcosm of the entire macrocosm, and in our intimate relation to it (to the creation made by God), the events of our salvation encompass all.

    St Sophrony also mentions that the chaos and battles in the world are also intimately related to the battles we encounter in our own soul. The ” in here”, in other words, in our hearts and souls, is intimately and closely related to the “out there”.

    And like St Dionysios says: “Beauty unites all things and is the source of all things.” and “From the One, the Good, the Beautiful, also –the intermingling of everything, the persistence of things, the unceasing emergence of things…”. With the image of God in us all, may we seek and see the Beauty of God, even and most importantly, among our enemies.

  23. Sam Avatar
    Sam

    Thank you very much, Dee. The quote from St Sophrony is particularly helpful.

  24. Bonnie Avatar
    Bonnie

    Dee, Thank you for that quotation. As Sam says, it is “particularly helpful.” Can you give its source?

  25. Nicole from VA Avatar
    Nicole from VA

    Michael, regarding joy, what a key it is! This past winter I did my first Psalter Prayer group, praying the Psalms in the 40 days before Christmas. God gave me a special gift as I noticed the phrase “To be a joyful mother of children” from Psalm 112. This has been a gift to me, and I am so encouraged by the gift of God’s joy that you show.

  26. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Sam,
    I think that our lives and creation are deeply intertwined. So, yes to your questions. Schmemann is a great source and there’s so much to meditate on all of this. Prayer, for example, can have a noted effect on growing things. Many stories out there.

  27. Dee of Sts Herman and Olga Avatar
    Dee of Sts Herman and Olga

    Hi Bonnie,
    I think it’s in his book called “His Life is Mine”. I’m at work and will look it up this evening.

  28. Michael Bauman Avatar
    Michael Bauman

    Joy is essential to life. We cannot know life without joy

  29. Dee of Sts Herman and Olga Avatar
    Dee of Sts Herman and Olga

    Dear Michael,
    Indeed joy is essential to the fullness of life and we know the fullness of life in gratitude and joy.

    As St Chrysostom said, “Glory to God for All Things”.

  30. Dee of Sts. Herman and Olga Avatar
    Dee of Sts. Herman and Olga

    Bonnie,
    I spent an hour or so looking for the succinct words I used to describe St Sophrony’s. I found places where it is obvious that is his the foundation of his words, but not as succinct as I wrote them. I’m going to write a few quotes that indicate his thoughts and insights.

    First I’ll mention the microcosm-macrocosm relationship I believe was first described by St Maximos. So this understanding is quite old in Orthodoxy.

    In his life is mine, St Sophrony describes the impact of deep prayer on the person who prays (p 60 chapter “Prayer of the Spirit), where we may be deformed and despised, wounded and rejected, many years of depraved living, but the moment we are resolved to follow His commandments, a process of basic healing begins. After a brief period of profound repentance, he says that he has witnessed a change in the person’s physical appearance, including their face, voice, and manner of movement.

    When we engage in “hypostatic” prayer, we break free of the shackles of individualism (how we are taught to see ourselves in Western culture) and enter into the expansive life of our personhood (pg 44) formed by love for Christ and for our brothers and sisters. We become “a worldwide radio receiver” of the tragedy of our existence, not only of individualized people but of the world at large; we pray for the world as we pray for our own selves.

    When we are physically ill we seek help from a physician, but when we spiritually suffer, we attribute our suffering to outside interference and often do not seek Christ, the soul’s physician (pg115).

    Adversity opens the heart to the suffering of the world. Through self-emptying, we become increasingly able to assume the tragedy of human history and to apprehend the mystery of Gethsemane and perhaps even of Golgotha (pg 114).

    St Sophrony wrote similar passages in the “Mystery of Christian Life” and “We shall see Him as He is”. In the latter book, there is a passage (pg 190) that infers that when we enter into this hypostatic prayer, at the same time the universe undergoes a certain alteration in its destinies.

    I’ll end by saying that hypostatic prayer is not only not easy, but St Sophony says it will feel like hell. St Silouan mentioned that Christ answered his prayer by saying something to the effect, “keep thy mind in hell and despair not”. That is because Christ is with us. St Sophrony also warns that keeping the mind on the edge of the abyss is exhausting, and one should step back from time to time and have a cup of tea.

  31. Bonnie Avatar
    Bonnie

    Dee, thank you for taking time to direct me to these points. I am writing a piece, hoping to tie together thoughts from St. Sophrony and St. Luke of Simferopol. I have the books you mentioned and your directions will help me a lot.
    Having grown up in a different tradition, I did not have a patron saint, so chose St. Sophrony. Then articles about St. Luke caught my attention. Both of them seem to be just right for our times.

  32. Mallory Avatar
    Mallory

    Thank you so much for this, Dee. I will have to buy these books. This, especially, consoles me: “I’ll end by saying that hypostatic prayer is not only not easy, but St Sophony says it will feel like hell.”

    When I started meditating years ago (just focusing on the breath), I could feel a connection to Christ, to the divine and it did indeed feel like hell. At first I could not sit for more than 20 minutes, and it was painful. After a few months of keeping at it, I didn’t notice a difference particularly, but people around me did. I had more patience, there was an ease about me. So naturally I stopped ha. Now I’ve traded that mostly for reading scripture in silence, but I know in my heart that I am missing prayer, the kind of prayer St Sophony speaks of, the kind of silence I was sitting in during those months. It’s hard to convince oneself to endure it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Subscribe to blog via email

Support the work

Your generous support for Glory to God for All Things will help maintain and expand the work of Fr. Stephen. This ministry continues to grow and your help is important. Thank you for your prayers and encouragement!


Latest Comments

  1. Thanks to you as well Mallory. If you´re willing to share, I´m wondering how your search for an Orthodox Church…

  2. I think I can perhaps understand, in a small way, why OCD might trigger oversensitivity to a judgmental God. They…


Read my books

Everywhere Present by Stephen Freeman

Listen to my podcast



Categories


Archives