The Mythic Character of Reality

The friendship between CS Lewis and JRR Tolkien is well-known, as is Tolkien’s role in bringing Lewis to Christ. Less well-known (unless you dig a bit further) is Tolkien’s role in bringing Lewis out of a rigid and flat understanding of the world and into the rich possibilities afforded by “myth.” Without this conversion, Lewis would likely not have become a Christian, and certainly would not have authored the fiction that is loved by so many. It is deeply underappreciated though it goes to the heart of both Lewis’ and Tolkien’s faith. They were not only Christians, they were Christians whose hearts were deeply touched and sympathetic to the power of myth. Through it, they gave us worlds that continue to entertain. However, most are entertained by their stories in the same way they are entertained by any action drama. The mythic character of their work is passed over and reduced to little more than “children’s fantasy.” Professor Digory says it well: “It’s all in Plato, all in Plato; bless me, what do  they teach them at these schools!”

The early conversations between Lewis and Tolkien were not about Christ, per se. They were about myth and the character of reality. Tolkien wrote a poem for Lewis (they both loved poetry), entitled “Philomythus to Misomythus” (“Lover of Myth to Hater of Myth”). One stanza reads:

He sees no stars who does not see them first
of living silver made that sudden burst
to flame like flowers beneath the ancient song,
whose very echo after-music long
has since pursued. There is no firmament,
only a void, unless a jewelled tent
myth-woven and elf-patterned; and no earth,
unless the mother’s womb whence all have birth.

The heart of the argument turned on the relationship of myth to reality. Lewis had said: “Myths are lies, even though breathed through silver.” Tolkien saw in mythic stories not lies, but a revelation of the very character of reality that could not be known or expressed in another manner. Modernity is fond of saying, “Beauty is in the eye of the beholder,” which is another way to say, “Beauty is merely subjective and not real. Beauty is a lie.” Modernity dismisses Tolkien as another fantasy author.

Tolkien once said, “If God is mythopoetic, we must become mythopathic.” Understanding this statement goes to the heart of Lewis’ Christian conversion and all of his subsequent work. Neither Tolkien nor Lewis (after his conversion) believed myth to mean “stories that are not true,” or mere “primitive efforts to explain what is not known.” Both were struck, not by the fictional aspect of myth (all myths), but by their profound insight into the nature of human existence and the world in which we live.

There is a reason, for example, that we discuss a certain kind of self-centered personality disorder as “Narcissistic,” making reference to a character in Greek mythology. Oedipal, erotic, cupidity, stygian, the Midas Touch, martial, and a host of other terms within our language make reference to ancient “myths,” not as an effort to be obscure, but because the stories within the myths carry a weight and a meaning that mere clinical language, devoid of such reference, lacks.

But both Lewis and Tolkien have something much more profound in mind. Lewis’ whimsical reference to Plato points to this fact. Somehow, myth is not just true, but real. The nature and character of the world cannot be described properly without reference to something more. That something more has a nature that gives shape to the stories labeled as myths. They are not just any story, a sub-genre of fiction. Indeed, even stories that would otherwise be labeled “true” and “real” (in the literal sense) have significance precisely in their mythic character.

Those who are “misomythic” are not necessarily anti-religious. However, their religion lacks power, beauty, and substance in that it is flat and empty. What modernity labels as “fact” is insufficient for human existence.

I have encountered such religion from time to time in a mindset that prides itself on the literal character of its faith. It will admit interpretations (of Scripture, for example) that have an allegorical or typological character (both of which seem to me to be sub-genres of myth). But, in fact, they are nominalists, granting such readings nothing more than a mental status, a literary trick. Such “tricks” are given some leeway in that they abound in the writings of the Fathers (and in the New Testament itself). But they deny that these readings are actually there: they are merely inferred.

When I have argued for the use of allegory or the “mystical” reading of Scripture, it is with reference to the actual character of reality and of the text itself. The universe is “one-storey,” something in which all that might be called mystical or mythical actually inheres. It is to be discerned.

St. Porphyrios said that in order to become a Christian, one must first become a poet. Poets, and “mythopoetic” above all else. Reading Lewis and Tolkien is not an exercise in literary fiction. Both, in different ways, understood themselves to be creating myth. Tolkien engaged in what he called an act of “sub-creation.” We feel it when we read him, with a strange aching sense that though we do not believe in his elves and orcs, they are, nonetheless, hauntingly real. I would say they have a sacramental character, embodying something that is real, but which we can only express in mythic form. Reading Tolkien should change how you see the world around you.

Lewis’ fiction is mythic in a different way. For Lewis, the primary “myth” (I would even say “Myth”) is that of Christ. He wrote:

As myth transcends thought, Incarnation transcends myth. The heart of Christianity is a myth which is also a fact. The old myth of the Dying God, without ceasing to be myth, comes down from the heaven of legend and imagination to the earth of history. It happens–at a particular date, in a particular place, followed by definable historical consequences. We pass from a Balder or an Osiris, dying nobody knows when or where, to a historical Person crucified (it is all in order) under Pontius Pilate. By becoming fact it does not cease to be myth: that is the miracle. I suspect that men have sometimes derived more spiritual sustenance from myths they did not believe than from the religion they professed. To be truly Christian we must both assent to the historical fact and also receive the myth (fact though it has become) with the same imaginative embrace which we accord to all myths. The one is hardly more necessary than the other…We must not be ashamed of the mythical radiance resting on our theology.

For many, the “mythical radiance” has been lost. What has taken place is the privileging of a secular account of reality. It is felt that we must win on the ground defined by secular materialism. The result is a modernized faith, even if the “facts” embraced are antique. My argument is like that of Tolkien and Lewis. God is mythopoetic. To understand Him requires that we learn the language in which He speaks and hear even the silence into which the Eternal Word is spoken.

About Fr. Stephen Freeman

Fr. Stephen is a retired Archpriest of the Orthodox Church in America. He is also author of Everywhere Present: Christianity in a One-Storey Universe, and Face to Face: Knowing God Beyond Our Shame, as well as the Glory to God podcast series on Ancient Faith Radio.



Posted

in

by

Comments

6 responses to “The Mythic Character of Reality”

  1. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    Hi Father,
    First, I love the photo you chose for this post. It invites wonder!
    Years ago, in his documentary, Religulous, Bill Maher argued against the authenticity of the Christian faith by pointing out that there was a non-Christian ancient text that also spoke about a virgin birth. And so, he argued, the biblical account is just an appropriation of a myth. To my younger self, he sounded so convincing but now it’s so clear to me how faulty his logic was.
    Myth and story and poetry and art, including photos:), invite us to search and seek and follow that ancient voice within us that leads us to reality.

  2. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Helen,
    The photo is from a while back. I was in Oxford, England. This is a bridge next to Magdalen College. It seemed an appropriate choice for an article invoking Lewis and Tolkien.

    It seems to me, with regard to various skeptics and critics of religion, that they are often not very creative. The argument about a pagan or mythic virgin birth is one that has been around since ancient times. Lewis once compared older pagan myths as “good dreams sent to us by God to prepare the way for when the dream becomes reality” (or something to that effect).

    It’s interesting to me to reflect on my first experiences in reading Tolkien and Lewis. I read Tolkien first, when I was in high school. I had never heard of his works, and knew nobody who did. An aunt gifted me the Hobbit and the Trilogy. She was a college professor and said, “Some of my students really like these.” I let them sit on a shelf for a good while, treating them like I did most gifts from an aunt…

    I caanot begin to describe the experience of reading those works as something of a “tabla rasa.” Very few people can have that experience today – with a culture replete with Tolkien and Tolkien-wannabe’s.

    I have a sense that passing from this life to the next is something similar to that first reading. What we have only seen dimly will pale utterly in the face of Reality unveiled. Also, the dross of our lives that is burned away in that arrival will allow us to see as we have never done before.

    Lewis’ The Great Divorce is the “real-est” description of the heavenly country that I know of – but he rightly describes it in terms of a “borderland” that gets ever better, brighter, larger, more real, etc. That is much like the theological vision of St. Gregory of Nyssa.

  3. Matthew Avatar
    Matthew

    Fr. Stephen wrote:

    “Lewis’ The Great Divorce is the “real-est” description of the heavenly country that I know of – but he rightly describes it in terms of a “borderland” that gets ever better, brighter, larger, more real, etc. That is much like the theological vision of St. Gregory of Nyssa.”

    Sometimes I have dreams where I will be looking at a particular landscape and in the dream I experience the beauty and color of the landscape at a level I cannot describe in words. It´s like a taste of the heavenly country; like I have left time and space for something much more real and for something much better.

  4. Fr. Stephen Avatar

    Matthew,
    A “sweet dream…”

    As a teenager (17 or so), I had a dream in which I was in a place where everything was “alive” in a sense that I cannot describe. But when I read The Great Divorce, I thought, “This is the place in the dream.” In the dream, the “aliveness” was so poignant, so piercing, that I could hardly bear it. It is among a handful of dreams that I recall rather vividly to this day, more than 5 decades later.

  5. Dee of Sts Herman and Olga Avatar
    Dee of Sts Herman and Olga

    Father,
    I have to admit that my mind draws a boundary between ‘myth’ and ‘reality’. But on the other hand, I have experienced reality in a way that someone else might say is a ‘myth’ or a subjective perception. So, I’m feeling unsure about word usage.

  6. Matthew Avatar
    Matthew

    Sweet dreams indeed!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Subscribe to blog via email

Support the work

Your generous support for Glory to God for All Things will help maintain and expand the work of Fr. Stephen. This ministry continues to grow and your help is important. Thank you for your prayers and encouragement!


Latest Comments

  1. Father, I have to admit that my mind draws a boundary between ‘myth’ and ‘reality’. But on the other hand,…

  2. Fr. Stephen wrote: “Lewis’ The Great Divorce is the “real-est” description of the heavenly country that I know of –…


Read my books

Everywhere Present by Stephen Freeman

Listen to my podcast



Categories


Archives